Your version of Minas Tirith represents a time of peace. I instantly thought of the fourth age of Middle-earth where Aragorn is king, and Gondor prospers.
To repeat what many others have said, I like the inclusions of farmlands on the Pelennor and the black stone of the outer wall.
I feel like there's got to be some way to make the black outer wall less visually jarring without hiding it behind trees... Maybe if the roofs in the city were also black? Regardless, I am quite impressed with this painting. While I think the movies did a good job overall, this artwork fits my own vision of Minas Tirith much better.
Not a bad idea about the roofs, it would add a nice defensive feature against fires and such. I've been kicking around some ideas about the Pelennor from different perspectives with the city as back drop. I'm sure there must be small villages throughout, waypoints on the way to Osgiliath, coming down from Rohan or up from Lebennin. Lots of ways to flesh out life on the Pelennor.
Thank you. I wanted a more realistic feel to the city than the one shown. It always amazes me how castles and cities are placed in the middle of nowhere in fantasy paintings. I'm just going the other way.
It has the general feel of the place and similarities to Minas Tirith as depicted in the PJ movies, but more true to how it was described in the novels and looks a bit more realistic (empty fields aside, the movies implied that Minas Tirith got its supplies from a harbour complex).
JRR would be proud but the farms are on the far left side of the city. right now, they're about to be trampled by a million Orcs and the riders of rohan
The Artist has requested Critique on this Artwork
Please sign up or login to post a critique.